MENTOR MONDAY: Developing Clinical Confidence: Helping Therapists Trust Their Judgment Without Overfunctioning
Clinical confidence is one of the most requested yet least clearly defined areas of professional growth for therapists. Many clinicians worry they are missing something, doing something wrong, or failing their clients when sessions feel uncertain. Others overprepare, overresearch, or overextend themselves in an attempt to feel competent. Over time, this pattern leads to exhaustion, rigidity, and loss of therapeutic creativity.
Mentor Monday is a space to talk honestly about professional development, especially the quiet struggles clinicians rarely name. One of those struggles is learning how to trust your clinical judgment without overfunctioning for clients or for the work itself.
Clinical confidence does not mean certainty. It does not mean knowing exactly what to say or do at all times. Instead, it reflects a therapist’s ability to tolerate ambiguity, remain grounded in formulation, and make thoughtful decisions without needing constant reassurance or perfection.
Many therapists mistakenly believe confidence comes from experience alone. While experience helps, confidence actually develops through integration. Integration of theory and intuition. Integration of mistakes and learning. Integration of feedback and self trust.
Why Therapists Struggle With Clinical Confidence
Most clinicians enter the field with strong empathy, high responsibility, and deep care for others. These strengths can also become vulnerabilities. When a therapist cares deeply, self doubt can easily arise.
Common contributors to reduced clinical confidence include:
• Early supervision that emphasized correction over affirmation
• High stakes client presentations such as trauma or suicidality
• Comparison to colleagues or social media portrayals of therapy
• Perfectionism disguised as professionalism
• Fear of causing harm
• Internalized pressure to perform rather than relate
• Limited tolerance for uncertainty
When confidence is fragile, therapists often cope by doing more. More notes. More research. More checking. More rescuing. More emotional labor.
This is where overfunctioning begins.
What Overfunctioning Looks Like in Clinical Practice
Overfunctioning is not always obvious. It often masquerades as dedication or excellence. Common signs include:
• Feeling responsible for the client’s progress
• Providing excessive psychoeducation to feel useful
• Talking more than the client
• Rushing insight or change
• Extending sessions emotionally beyond what is therapeutic
• Difficulty holding boundaries
• Overpreparing for sessions
• Feeling depleted after most sessions
Overfunctioning temporarily reduces anxiety but ultimately erodes confidence. The therapist learns to rely on effort rather than trust.
Clinical Confidence Comes From Tolerating Uncertainty
Therapy is inherently uncertain. Even the most seasoned clinicians encounter sessions where they feel lost, unsure, or unsure of the next step. Confidence is not the absence of these moments. Confidence is staying present through them.
A confident therapist can say internally:
• I do not need to fix this right now
• I can sit with not knowing
• The process matters more than immediate clarity
• The relationship is doing important work
When therapists learn to tolerate uncertainty, they stop panicking in it. This allows intuition and clinical reasoning to emerge naturally.
Rebuilding Trust in Your Clinical Judgment
Clinical judgment is not guesswork. It is a blend of training, experience, attunement, and ethical reasoning. To rebuild trust in it, therapists can practice the following:
1. Name What You Do Know
Even when sessions feel unclear, something is always known. You may know the client feels unsafe, stuck, overwhelmed, or ambivalent. Naming what is clear builds internal grounding.
2. Separate Anxiety From Clinical Information
Anxiety often sounds urgent and loud. Clinical intuition is quieter. Learning to distinguish between the two is essential.
3. Reflect After Sessions
Instead of asking, “Did I do this right?” ask, “What did I notice?” This shift supports learning rather than self criticism.
4. Seek Consultation for Reflection, Not Validation
Use consultation to explore perspectives, not to be told what to do. This strengthens independent thinking.
The Role of Supervision in Clinical Confidence
Supervision plays a crucial role in shaping confidence. Supervisors who ask reflective questions instead of giving constant direction help clinicians learn to think clinically rather than perform.
Helpful supervision questions include:
• What felt important in that moment
• What options did you consider
• What made you choose that intervention
• How did your body respond during the session
These questions reinforce the therapist’s internal decision making process.
Letting Go of the Need to Perform
Many therapists unknowingly perform therapy rather than practice it. Performance shows up as pressure to say the right thing, use the perfect intervention, or appear confident.
Clients benefit far more from authenticity than performance. A therapist who is grounded and present creates safety. Safety allows change.
Clinical confidence grows when therapists allow themselves to be human in the room while remaining professional.
Confidence and Ethical Practice
Ethical practice requires self awareness. Therapists who lack confidence may overstep boundaries or avoid necessary conversations out of fear. Therapists with healthy confidence can:
• Set clear boundaries
• Address ruptures
• Say no when appropriate
• Acknowledge limits
• Refer when necessary
Confidence supports ethical clarity.
Practicing From a Grounded Center
When therapists stop overfunctioning, they practice from a grounded center. This means:
• Trusting the process
• Allowing silence
• Letting clients lead when appropriate
• Intervening thoughtfully rather than urgently
• Holding boundaries with compassion
This style of practice is more sustainable and more effective.
Clinical Confidence Is a Relationship With Yourself
At its core, clinical confidence is not about skill mastery. It is about the relationship you have with yourself as a clinician.
Do you trust yourself to be present
Do you allow yourself to learn
Do you treat uncertainty as failure or as information
Do you offer yourself the same compassion you offer clients
When therapists answer these questions honestly, confidence begins to grow naturally.
Final Reflection
You do not need to be perfect to be effective. You do not need certainty to be competent. You do not need to overfunction to be valuable.
Your presence matters.
Your judgment matters.
Your steadiness matters.
Clinical confidence develops when you allow yourself to practice from trust instead of fear.
Explore our free mental health resources. They may benefit your patients.
🆓 Download our FREE Mental Wellness Workbook + Therapy Themed Affirmation Cards, or share them with those you support:
👉 https://www.serenepathways.com/free-offerings
📍 11800 Central Ave, Suite 225, Chino, CA
📞 909-591-5085 | 📧 Stuartkaplowitz@serenepathways.com
🌐 www.serenepathways.com
#DevelopingClinicalConfidence #MentorMonday #TherapistGrowth #ClinicianDevelopment #TherapistLife #ClinicalSupervision #TherapistWellbeing #MentalHealthProfessionals #TherapistSupport #EvidenceBasedPractice #SerenePro #ProviderToProvider